Articulated fossil brachiopod shells have been used extensively to extract primary chemical information of Phanerozoic seawater. Despite the selection of well-preserved shells using trace element, microstructure and cathodoluminescence criteria, there are still concerns as to whether the selected brachiopod shells do indeed contain original seawater signals. Analyzed in-situ by Laser Ablation-Inductively Coupled Plasma-Mass Spectrometry (LAICPMS), Sr, Na, Mg, Mn, B and Ba distribute symmetrically in shell transects of the modern brachiopods Magellania flavescens and Terebratulina septentrionalis. Symmetry of the trace element distribution pattern is considered an intrinsic and original ontogenetic property of the brachiopod shell chemistry. The trace element distribution is symmetrical in a well-preserved shell of the Devonian brachiopod Independatrypa lemma, indicating that the selected shell by the conventional criteria has preserved its original seawater signal for 400 Ma. In another specimen of I. lemma that is considered diagenetically altered, trace element concentrations are asymmetrically distributed in the shell. The agreement between the distribution criteria and the conventional methods indicates the latter can be used to select brachiopod shells with original seawater chemistry. The average element concentration in the whole shell of unaltered brachiopods should be a reflection of the seawater chemistry, while its change in different part of a shell reflects ontogenetic effect, and its high frequent fluctuations in a transect are results of changes in environmental parameters with seasonal or annual characteristics.